Requiem for a Union Town

How the fight went out of Windsor
Workers march out of Chrysler's Windsor Assembly Plant minutes before a 1982 strike deadlineWorkers march out of Chrysler’s Windsor Assembly Plant minutes before a 1982 strike deadline

When the telephone rang, it was about 8:30 p.m. on Monday, March 9, and Mike Melo was sitting on the couch watching TV at his parents’ home in Windsor, Ontario. The woman on the other end identified herself as the human resources manager at the stamping plant where he had worked for twelve years at a job that paid him $21 an hour. Chrysler was ordering an immediate halt to production, she told him. Neither he nor any of the shop’s other twenty-eight employees were to show up the next morning. They were laid off — effective immediately.

Melo is thirty-four years old, with dark hair, a medium build, and a goatee. He often wears a baseball cap pulled low over his eyes, and carries himself with a confidence suggesting that in his youth he would have been one of the boys picking teams at the local sandlot. At his stamping plant, Aramco, owned by American auto supplier Catalina Precision Products, he was the union steward — the elected leader who represents workers in their dealings with management.

Ontario labour law dictates that terminated employees receive severance pay according to their seniority, but when termination results from a shop closure, there’s a strong risk that workers will get no severance at all. Melo felt certain Aramco was shutting down permanently. One of two plants formerly owned by a pair of local brothers, it made hood hinges, battery trays, and tail light casements for such Chrysler vehicles as the Dodge Dakota and Ram pickup trucks. Catalina had bought Aramco and the other shop, Aradco, in September 2006, hoping to get work from other manufacturers. When that plan failed, worrisome signs began to crop up: if a gear snapped in a press, managers opted to weld it back together rather than buy a new one. Instead of repairing forklifts, they parked the vehicles and forgot about them. “It was just a feeling you got,” says Melo, “that things were going downhill.”

Melo belonged to caw Local 195, the oldest automotive local in the country. Shortly after receiving the phone call, he began getting in touch with his union brothers and sisters: his vice-chair, Pat Ganney; the national representative to the caw, his good friend Mike Renaud; and dozens of others. At some point during the speed dialing, the idea of a blockade was proposed and agreed upon. “It was almost a given,” says Melo. “In this situation, here’s what you do.”

According to the union’s calculations, Catalina’s two shuttered shops owed their eighty-odd employees about $1.5 million in back pay, vacation pay, and severance. Melo and his co-workers believed the only way they’d get it was by holding the equipment at the shops hostage — in particular the Chrysler-owned moulds (commonly referred to as “tools”) that were the most valuable assets in the plants.

The workers began arriving at the Aramco parking lot around 6:30 Tuesday morning. It only had two gates, and thus only two spots accessible by tractor-trailer. The union members set about blocking these off with their North American–made vehicles. Then they dragged over some picnic benches, opened their Tim Hortons cups, and sat down for a long wait. Over at Aradco, a similar scene was unfolding.

The first of Chrysler’s trucks showed up at Aramco on Thursday. It encountered a line of workers set up across the yard entrance. For a while, the driver idled his rig in front of them, creating a standoff that looked like a small-scale Tiananmen Square. Eventually the truck left. It was early in the following week before another one showed up, this time accompanied by Windsor police cruisers. The workers again stood firm, and again the truck withdrew.

Without parts from Catalina’s two shops, Chrysler assembly lines across North America faced wide-ranging production stoppages that were certain to cost the company — already facing bankruptcy — millions of dollars a day. Six days after the protest started, the company responded, offering Local 195 a severance package of $205,000, to be distributed among shop employees entitled to vacation pay that year. Local president Gerry Farnham endorsed the deal, saying it was the best the union could hope for. But the workers disagreed; that evening, 64 percent of them rejected the offer.

At that point, Melo and other union reps began to discuss breaking into one of the plants and barricading themselves inside. Lawyers representing Chrysler and the union were arguing over whether the automaker was legally allowed to force its way into the Catalina shops. The workers knew that if a judge granted the company an injunction to enter the plants, the only way to prolong the protest would be an occupation. “We were ready to do what we had to do,” Melo says.

This was just the sort of fight Windsor had been spoiling for. A feeling of injustice pervaded the city as the recession began to take its toll. No burg in Canada is as dependent on automobile manufacturing as Windsor, where Chrysler, Ford, and General Motors have been the top three employers for years. According to the city’s manufacturers directory, some 15,000 of Windsor’s 200,000 residents work directly for a Big Three automaker or a top-tier supplier. Thousands more work for stamping plants, tool and die shops, and mould makers. And thousands of others have jobs in the health care and service sectors that come and go depending on the number of North American vehicles sold in any given year. The result is an urban ecosystem almost entirely sustained by the production of cars and trucks.

Early in the year, everyone I spoke to told a story that illuminated the city’s distress. GM had announced plans to eliminate its Windsor Transmission Plant in 2010, effectively pulling out of town. Ford had laid off about 40 percent of its workers. The city’s unemployment rate was the highest of any urban area in the country. And then, at the beginning of March, came what may have been the most psychologically damaging blow of all: Chrysler’s Windsor Assembly Plant, the economic marvel that had churned out minivans in twenty-four-hour, three-shift production cycles since 1993, was cutting a shift.

It wasn’t just the additional 1,200 employees who would now be out of work. It was an indication of the way things had changed. If people weren’t even buying utilitarian minivans, then the situation was worse than anyone thought. And it had symbolic significance. Chrysler, more than the other Big Three companies, occupies a special place in Windsor’s consciousness. Its Canadian headquarters is a prominent bump on the city’s skyline. The Peace Fountain, in a park on the Detroit River, memorializes Charlie Brooks, the man who founded Local 444 in the Chrysler Assembly Plant. And a former Chrysler executive lent his name to the city’s most travelled highway, the E. C. Row Expressway.

These are things you just know when you grow up in Windsor, as I did. And yet when I think of my hometown, my mind doesn’t summon images of assembly plants. In fact, I didn’t realize how integral the auto industry was to Windsor’s identity until after I left for university. Only then did I grasp what people meant by “blue collar,” and once I understood that Windsor epitomized the concept I spent a few years rolling my eyes at the mere mention of the place. I also worked on dropping some characteristic hometown traits, like the tendency to dismiss anyone with ambition as a keener or brown-noser, and the habit of pronouncing “them” as “thum.” During my last years in university, I was in a long-distance relationship with a girl from home. She was beautiful and smart, but we bickered endlessly over the future. I wasn’t moving back; she wasn’t moving away. Her excuse was the job she had on the line at “Ford’s.” I pushed her to switch from part-time studies at the University of Windsor to full time at some other school — a step that would have required her to give up her union job. She never did.

I married another girl, also from Windsor. We settled in Toronto. Now that we have kids, we sometimes discuss moving back. After years away from the place, I’ve grown to miss certain things about it. When I was a boy, my family lived on the north shore of Essex County, on a stretch of Lake
St. Clair beachfront twenty minutes from downtown. From the vantage of our beach, you could see the smokestacks of Detroit and, on a clear day, the shore of Grosse Pointe, where the Ford family had a much-ogled lakefront property. The Canadian side of the lake was far more equitable. Most of my neighbours were auto workers, or people who enjoyed the benefits of an economy dominated by the industry. Back then, you were considered lucky if your parents were auto workers. You were set. When they were on the day shift, they arrived home at 4 p.m., so you could eat by 4:30 and still have a good four hours before bed. That left time for hockey games on the lakefront rink and snowmobile rides on the ice. Time for bike rides and water skiing. It wasn’t so much that the auto workers’ kids got Atari 2600s or Cooperalls; it was that their parents were around for them — for the soccer practices and hockey championships, the ballet recitals and fashion shows.

Windsorites didn’t define themselves by their jobs. That’s probably why I don’t think of cars when I think of Windsor; it’s certainly why my ex-girlfriend opted to settle for a factory job. Income calculated on what is now a base wage of $33 an hour, with health benefits and a guaranteed pension, allowed auto workers to concentrate on anything but their work. They defined themselves by their hobbies, whether it was photography or mountain biking. And they defined themselves by their familial responsibilities, their roles as fathers and mothers. Now that I have a family, I’ve come to understand that ours was a middle-class paradise, and that this paradise existed because of gains a radical and militant caw had won for its members over the years — gains that had trickled down, in turn, to eyeglass shop clerks, pizzeria owners, and members of the Windsor professional class (of whom my father was one). When auto sales were booming, when the overtime was rolling in, there wasn’t a better place in Canada to grow up.

HomePage 1 of 3Next
5 comment(s)

Randall St JacquesSeptember 22, 2009 22:19 EST

Great peace of literature! I know my grandfather, one of the many who walked out of Chrysler with George Burt in 1940, is spinning in his grave.These guys had guts! The company had persuaded the government to declare the Windsor Assembly passenger car plant necessary for the war effort, thus relieving the company of the necessity to bargain at all for a contract.They struck anyway and were led out the gates into paddywagons.It's a great story, one almost forgotten. The spirit and intestinal fortitude displayed by the Chrysler workers spread to Ford and GM. Those qualities aren't dead; they're just dormant and can be re-awakened. It's up to the rank and file to provide the leaders who are up to the job. Strength flows from within! Walrus gets my 3 bucks just for "Requiem for a Union Town". However, I believe recuperation is possible.

Tracey RamseySeptember 24, 2009 10:45 EST

Lots of great information, but the perception that Windsor's days are over is not accurate. We are transitioning, true, but there are still many good people living good lives in Windsor/Essex County. There are many educated auto workers who are now returning to their previous careers, as nurses, lawyers, engineers, and many others who are headed to school for the first time.
The College & University are at maximum enrollment. With 65% mature students at the college alone, the governments Second Career Program is alive and well and finally making good use of the EI surplus we've all paid into.
The reason educated people have maintained these "blue collar" jobs is the LIFEstyle it has afforded them, life being the operative word, not WORK. Being defined by your LIFE and not your WORK is the reason we are all here on this third rock from the sun.

As a Ford Employee currently in talks to give concessions, we are hoping to make the deals that have been established in the past to secure a manufacturing footprint in Canada, that existed until the government removed the Auto Pact. I am also now a full time student at the college, planning for an alternative future if I never return to automotive.
The slow death of manufacturing in Canada is a never ending battle, and unless we pressure politicians to stand up for Canadians, we will only continue to see other manufacturing sectors suffer the way Windsor has.
We are now in a race to the bottom, by making concessions, but it is not the first time and won't be the last that we have made them to secure a future in Canada.

Scott PattisonSeptember 24, 2009 12:46 EST

As a proud Windsorite, I too, am grateful for the standard of living that the CAW and the Chryslers afforded my family.

To park a Honda or a Toyota in the driveway of a parent employed by the Big 3, was a mistake not soon forgotten, as I foolishly learned.

And although my career has taken me west, my community, Windsor, with all of its economic might and weakness, has forever left its mark on my character.

Through downturns and times of prosperity, Windsorites have always prevailed, their collective resilience unparalleled across the Canadian landscape.

No-one rides the rollercoaster like those in Motor City-North. You know what I mean!

FTR, a Dodge is still parked in my driveway, and a bottle of Heinz Ketchup in the fridge!

dig the online treasureNovember 06, 2009 01:45 EST

I am also grateful for a given standard of living of my family. I do not mistake forget is when the car broke the rear view mirror jazz. thanks for sharing information, experiences very interesting.

G-raidDecember 10, 2009 14:02 EST

Sure makes you think if unions are necessary and if there are ways that we can improve them.

Comment on this article
  
I agree to walrusmagazine.com’s comments policy.

Canada & its place in the world. Published by
the non-profit charitable Walrus Foundation
TwitterFacebookRSS
On newsstands now
New Issue on Sale
March 2012
Subscribe online for as little as $2.49 an issue. Visit The Walrus Store
to buy prints of our covers
The Walrus Laughs
Search the web, support the Walrus Foundation
COPA